The Myth of “I Just Need More Motivation”
How many times have you said it — or heard it from another runner? “I’d be fine if I just had more motivation.” It sounds logical, but it’s usually not true. Motivation is fleeting. It’s loud on race day, quiet on a random Tuesday, and completely MIA when life gets messy.
What athletes really need isn’t more motivation. It’s self-trust.
Why Self-Trust Beats Motivation Every Time
When you trust yourself, you don’t need to wait around for the spark to show up. You know you’ll follow through because you’ve proven it before. That doesn’t mean you never skip a run or change a plan — it means you trust your decisions either way.
Think about it:
-
Motivation tells you to run when the weather is perfect.
-
Self-trust gets you out the door when it’s raining, because you know it’ll still be worth it.
-
Motivation hypes you up for the first week of a new plan.
-
Self-trust is what keeps you steady in week seven when the shine has worn off.
Self-trust is built, not borrowed. And that’s why it’s stronger.
How to Start Building Self-Trust
The first step is simple: keep promises to yourself. That could be as small as lacing up for 15 minutes when you said you would, or hitting “start” on your strength routine instead of scrolling. Every time you follow through, you add a brick to the foundation of trust.
The second step is just as important: don’t punish yourself for adjusting. Life will happen. Kids get sick. Work blows up. Hormones tank your sleep. Self-trust doesn’t mean perfection — it means you believe your decisions are in service of your bigger goals, even when they look different than you planned.
Over time, the question shifts from “Do I feel like it?” to “Do I trust myself to show up?”
A Word for Masters & Menopausal Athletes
This matters even more as you age or move through menopause. Recovery is different. Energy is different. Some days your body says “not today” — and listening to that isn’t weakness, it’s wisdom.
When you build self-trust, you stop spiraling about missed workouts and start respecting the long game. That shift keeps you consistent far longer than chasing motivation ever will.
Mapping It Back to Your Resources
If this hits home, here are some ways to dig deeper:
-
Choose-Your-Own-Adventure Resource → A tool for athletes who feel stuck or burned out and need to rekindle joy in movement.
-
1:1 Coaching → If you want support building confidence, consistency, and a plan that actually fits your life.
-
Mindset Reset Mini-Course → For athletes who want practical ways to rewire habits and focus.
Self-Trust FAQ
How is self-trust different from discipline?
Discipline often feels rigid — “do it no matter what.” Self-trust is more flexible. It’s about knowing when to push and when to rest, and believing that both choices move you forward.
What if I’ve broken promises to myself before?
Start small. Pick something so achievable you can’t fail — like a 10-minute walk. Each time you follow through, you rebuild the trust you thought you lost.
Can self-trust really replace motivation?
Yes. Motivation is a spark; self-trust is the engine. Sparks are nice, but you don’t get anywhere without the engine.
Why is this important for runners over 40?
Because consistency is everything. Self-trust helps you stay consistent, even when recovery, hormones, or life throw curveballs. Motivation won’t carry you through those — trust will.
Motivation will always come and go. That’s not a character flaw — that’s human nature. But self-trust? That sticks.
When you trust yourself, you don’t waste energy waiting for the perfect moment to feel inspired. You know you can handle the messy, the imperfect, the “I don’t feel like it” days — and still move forward.
You don’t need more motivation. You need more trust in yourself. And that’s something you can start building today.